House vs Apartment: Which is Better for First Home Buyers?

Buying your first home comes with one big question that almost every Australian first home buyer faces: Should I buy a house or an apartment?

In this episode of the Your First Home Buyer Guide Podcast, Veronica and Meighan draw on their combined 50 years of buyer's agent experience to unpack the pros and cons of each option—so you can make an informed choice that suits your budget, lifestyle, and long-term goals.
Whether you're navigating affordability challenges, deciding between location and space, or wondering about capital growth potential, this conversation will help you weigh up the trade-offs and avoid costly mistakes.
 

Key Takeaways from This Episode

1. It's Part of the Bigger "Where Should I Buy?" Question
The house vs apartment decision can't be made in isolation. It's tied to your "3P" mix:

• Position (location)
• Property (type and features)
• Price (budget)

Each factor influences the others, and the right balance will be different for everyone.

2. Apartments – The Advantages
• Lower Entry Price – Generally cheaper than houses in the same suburb, allowing you to get into the market sooner.
• Better Location for the Budget – Lets you live closer to work, amenities, and lifestyle hubs.
Easier to Lock Up and Leave – Ideal if you plan to travel, move interstate, or keep the property as an investment.
• Potential Stepping Stone Strategy – With the right choice, you can retain it as a rental when you upgrade.
• Shared Maintenance Costs – Major repairs are split between owners via strata levies.
• Renovations Can Be Simpler – Cosmetic upgrades are usually easier and cheaper (though still subject to strata approval).

3. Apartments – The Drawbacks
• Risk of Oversupply – Especially in some city pockets with many "cookie-cutter" investor units, which can impact capital growth.
• Strata Levies and Rules – Ongoing fees and regulations about renovations, pets, and even where you can hang your washing.
• Potential to Outgrow Quickly – Limited ability to expand or add rooms.
• Slower Capital Growth (Generally) – Houses often outperform apartments long-term, but well-chosen apartments in scarce locations can still do well.

4. Houses – The Advantages
• Land Content Drives Growth – You own the land, which is often the key to stronger long-term capital growth.
• More Space and Flexibility – Outdoor areas, room to expand, and freedom to renovate without strata approval.
• Grows with You – You can extend, reconfigure, or adapt the home as your needs change.
• Fewer Rules – More personal control over your property without a body corporate.

5. Houses – The Drawbacks
• Higher Entry Cost – More expensive than an apartment in the same location.
• More Responsibility – 100% of repair and maintenance costs fall on you.
• Likely to Be Further from the Action – For the same budget, you'll often need to move further from the CBD or lifestyle precincts.
• Potentially Difficult Neighbours – Without strata rules, disputes are handled directly or through local council/police.

6. No One-Size-Fits-All Answer
The best choice depends on:
• Your budget flexibility
• Desired location and lifestyle priorities
• Long-term property goals
• Whether you value land ownership or city convenience
• Local market conditions and scarcity of the property type

Veronica and Meighan stress that there are no blanket rules—only principles to guide your decision. A poor-quality house won't outperform a great apartment, and vice versa. The key is matching the property to your needs and future plans while avoiding common pitfalls.

 👉 Ready to get started? Check out THE First Home Buyer Course.

Episode Highlights:
● Meighan's featured house for the episode (The Flintstone House) [02:17]
● Why this question needs to be tackled & clarified [04:07]
● What are some apartment pros? [06:15]
     ● Apartments have a lower price point [07:56]
     ● The potential to keep the property as an investment [08:46]
     ● There's more flexibility with owning a house than an apartment [12:37]
     ● Apartments are easier to renovate (with a few constraints) [13:08]
     ● Costs are shared between you and other tenants in the complex [15:17]
● Apartment cons [16:49]
     ● The tendency to outgrow the space quicker [16:54]
     ● There's a danger of having an oversupply [18:45]
     ● Strata fees [20:03]
     ● A complex's special rules for pets, air-conditioning, and others [21:51]
     ● They typically have a slower capital growth [25:11]
● Let's talk about house pros! [26:11]
     ● The potential to extend and build on your property [27:17]
     ● There's more freedom to do what you want, when you want [28:12]
     ● You can choose what renovations to do depending on your budget [30:03]
● A house is more expensive than an apartment [31:45]
● If anything goes wrong, 100% of it is your problem! [32:13]
● Houses are generally further away from the CBD, for the same price [33:10]
● Neighbours aren't governed by the same rules as strata neighbours [34:22]
Links from the Show:
● Check out the Stepping Stone Tutorial
● Get fully prepared to buy property through Your First Home Buyer Guide!
● Our episode on Building & Pest Inspections with Peter Masia
If you enjoyed today's podcast, don't forget to subscribe, rate and share the show! There's more to come, so we hope to have you along with us on this journey!
Loading...
Learn how to buy your first home without making avoidable mistakes.
  Co-Founders

Veronica Morgan & Meighan Wells 

Veronica & Meighan are both licensed real estate agents who exclusively help buyers. Together they have nearly 40 years experience as property professionals.

Veronica is principal of Sydney based Good Deeds Property Buyers and is also co-host of The Elephant in the Room property podcast as well as Location Location Location Australia on Foxtel and author of Auction Ready: how to buy property at auction even though you're scared s#!tless!

Meighan is the multi award winning principal of Brisbane based Property Pursuit, chairperson of the REIQ Buyers Agent Chapter & a regular media commentator.